Sacred & Secular

Sacred & Secular

What If We Could Disagree Without Losing Each Other?

Why our fear of disagreement may be stopping us from discovering what Christian community could really be.

Paul Ian Clarke's avatar
Paul Ian Clarke
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid
An ancient biblical manuscript with commentary written alongside the text.
An ancient biblical manuscript with commentary written alongside the text. Generations of readers have approached Scripture with questions, interpretations and a desire to understand. Medieval Acre Bible, Château de Chantilly. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Welcome to today’s reflection.

Today I reflect on why disagreement can feel so threatening in our churches, and what an ancient Jewish tradition might teach us about finding room for different opinions without losing one another.

In all the churches I have been involved with, I have noticed something curious about the way churches handle disagreement. For communities that spend so much time studying a library filled with arguments, difficult questions and competing interpretations, we can be surprisingly uncomfortable when somebody disagrees with us.

In fact, I often felt that churches went out of their way to avoid disagreement altogether, almost as though having different opinions was a sign that something had gone wrong. Don’t get me wrong, disagreements can be destructive, particularly when people stop listening to one another. But I was never convinced that avoiding difficult conversations completely was the answer.

I have spent a considerable amount of time encouraging people to question, challenge and openly debate Scripture. I wanted them to feel comfortable enough to say when they understood a passage differently, or that they weren't convinced by something they had heard. I wanted them to know that disagreeing with me, or with one another, wouldn't make them any less welcome.

It sounds straightforward enough, but in practice I always found it a difficult process.

I think part of the problem is that disagreement often feels much more personal than we like to admit. Our beliefs aren’t simply abstract ideas floating around in our heads. They are tied to our experiences, the people who taught us and sometimes the most difficult periods of our lives. When somebody challenges those beliefs, we may feel that something precious is being threatened.

But I wonder whether there is another fear beneath all this. The fear that if we express what we really think, particularly when it differs from those around us, we might somehow find ourselves on the outside.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Paul Ian Clarke.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Paul Ian Clarke · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.