
Welcome to the Sunday reflection.
Today I reflect on why Jesus repeatedly told people not to spread the news about him, even after performing extraordinary miracles.
As an introvert, you might think that making myself stand out in any way is something I would avoid. I think it is part of why I have a love/hate relationship with my wheelchair. But there is one way I never mind standing out: when I wear a clerical collar.
It feels like magic. One minute I am invisible, then I put it on and people approach me with questions about God, Christianity or Jesus. Sometimes they don’t have a question at all. They simply want to tell me what they believe.
That might sound a bit demanding, particularly if you’re trying to get somewhere, but it is actually one of my favourite parts of wearing a collar. People seem to feel safe raising subjects they might never discuss with a stranger otherwise. If it gets too much, I can just remove it.
In the early days, though, I was constantly astonished by the range of opinions I encountered.
Some were convinced Jesus had never existed and that the whole story had been invented. They seemed particularly keen to inform me of this. Others offered elaborate conspiracy theories that required extensive explanation. I love (most of these) conversations, even when we disagreed, but occasionally they left me feeling sad.
Some people seem to spend an extraordinary amount of time constructing an explanation of Jesus without being particularly interested in what he actually said or did. After all, there is a difference between questioning what Jesus meant by loving your neighbour and deciding he was the product of an alien conspiracy (honestly, I had that conversation).
Those encounters left me thinking about the difference between having an opinion about Jesus and understanding him. It turns out that the Gospels raise a surprisingly similar question.
And I think it is why Jesus often tells people not to tell anyone after he had performed a miracle.
❦
Why keep a miracle secret?
In Mark 1, a man with a serious skin disease approaches Jesus and begs to be healed. Jesus touches him, heals him and then gives him a stern warning:
“See that you don’t tell this to anyone.” (Mark 1:44)
He tells the man to present himself to the priest and make the offering required by Moses, but not to spread the news. Of course, the man ignores him and talks about the healing openly (who could keep that quiet?!). According to Mark, the resulting publicity makes it difficult for Jesus to enter towns.
That offers us a perfectly practical explanation for the silence. Jesus was trying to teach and travel, and overwhelming crowds made doing both harder. In Mark 7, he takes a deaf man aside to heal him and again tells those present not to publicise it. Once again, they spread the news anyway, apparently unable to contain their excitement.
Yet avoiding crowds cannot explain every instruction. Jesus also silences unclean spirits that recognise him, and he tells his own disciples not to announce that he is the Messiah. There seems to be more going on than the difficulty of getting through a village without being mobbed.
And then Mark includes a story that complicates the whole idea.
❦
The man Jesus told to tell everyone
In Mark 5, Jesus meets a troubled man living among the tombs in the region of the Gerasenes. He has been isolated from his community, restrained with chains and regarded as someone nobody can manage. After Jesus heals him, the local people find him sitting there, dressed and in his right mind.
The man wants to travel with Jesus, and I can understand why. Having been restored to something resembling an ordinary life, he wants to stay close to the person responsible. But Jesus refuses and gives him another task:
“Go home to your own people and tell them how much the Lord has done for you.” (Mark 5:19)
That is almost the opposite of what Jesus told the man in Mark 1, so what is going on?
One explanation is the setting. This healing takes place in a region associated with the Decapolis, where many people would not have shared the same expectations of a Jewish Messiah as those in Galilee. Perhaps speaking openly about Jesus was less likely to stir up political hopes there.
It sounds convincing until we return to the deaf man in Mark 7. His healing also takes place in the Decapolis region, yet Jesus tells people to remain silent. Geography alone doesn’t solve it.
There may have been several reasons for these different instructions. In the Gerasene man’s case, telling his own community what had happened was perhaps more important than travelling with Jesus. What I find interesting is that Jesus doesn’t seem to be following a single publicity policy. Instead, he responds to particular people and circumstances.
But there is one encounter where Mark gives us a much clearer indication of what might be at stake.
❦
Peter gets the answer right
In Mark 8, Jesus asks his disciples, “Who do people say I am?”
The answers are varied. Some say John the Baptist, others Elijah or one of the prophets. It sounds a bit like those street conversations I have, although, thankfully, I don’t remember anyone suggesting John the Baptist had returned when they saw my collar.
Then Jesus asks the disciples what they think.
Peter replies, “You are the Messiah.”
For Christians reading Mark today, that sounds like the correct answer. Yet Jesus immediately orders them not to tell anyone about him. Crucially, the next few verses help explain why.
Jesus begins teaching that he must suffer, be rejected and killed, and then rise again. Peter is appalled. He takes Jesus aside and begins to rebuke him. Whatever Peter thought the Messiah would do, suffering and death were not part of the plan.
Jesus responds sharply: “Get behind me, Satan! You do not have in mind the concerns of God, but merely human concerns.” (Mark 8:33)
Peter has identified Jesus correctly and then tried to correct him. I find that a fascinating, rather uncomfortable combination.
The word Messiah carried significant hopes. Some Jewish people longed for a deliverer who would free Israel from foreign rule and restore its fortunes. Expectations varied, of course, but Peter’s reaction suggests that the Messiah he imagined most definitely did not end up rejected and executed.
Perhaps this was one danger of announcing Jesus’ identity too early. People could hear the right title and fill it with their own expectations that Jesus had no intention of meeting.
❦
What they couldn’t yet see
We are going on a whistle-stop tour of Mark today, as there is another clue in Mark 9.
Peter, James and John witness the Transfiguration, when Jesus’ appearance changes before them and a voice declares him God’s beloved Son. It is hard to imagine a more dramatic experience to tell others about.
Yet Jesus again instructs them to keep it to themselves, this time until after the Son of Man has risen from the dead.
That final phrase matters. At least in this instance, silence has an endpoint. The disciples are to wait until the cross and resurrection have changed their understanding of what they have seen.
Scholars disagree about how to explain all the secrecy commands in Mark. Some emphasise the practical problems caused by crowds. Others see Mark using secrecy to help readers gradually understand Jesus’ identity, rather than assuming every instruction has the same historical purpose.
Still, Peter’s experience offers an important insight. Recognising something true about Jesus isn’t necessarily the same as understanding him. You can get the name right and still expect the wrong person entirely.
❦
The Jesus we think we know
I think that is why those unexpected street conversations are one of my favourite things. I met people who think seriously about Christianity and others whose ideas seemed to have travelled a very long way from the Gospels.
Yet, it would be too easy to imagine that the danger belongs only to people with unusual theories.
After all, Peter wasn’t standing outside the story making wild guesses. He had travelled with Jesus, heard him teach and witnessed his miracles. Even so, when Jesus described a future Peter didn’t want to accept, he actually tried to talk Jesus out of it
In my years reading, preaching and writing about Jesus, I still encounter passages that make me reconsider what I thought I understood. Sometimes he is more challenging than I remember. Sometimes he is more compassionate than I expect.
Familiarity can make it surprisingly easy to stop listening. I think that is one reason I enjoy returning to these stories and writing about them. There is nearly always something I haven't noticed before.
Perhaps that is what makes Jesus’ repeated requests for silence so intriguing. They leave me wondering whether he was sometimes less concerned about people knowing who he was than about what they would do with that knowledge.
And if even Peter could recognise the Messiah while misunderstanding what that meant, I suspect the rest of us still have plenty to learn.
Thank you for reading today’s free reflection. Every Sunday, I share a reflection like this with everyone, while paid subscribers receive a new reflection each weekday that explores Scripture, faith, and the questions that arise in ordinary life.
If you’ve enjoyed today’s article, I’d love to welcome you as a paid subscriber. Your support helps keep Sacred & Secular going, makes these daily reflections possible and allows me to continue sharing Sunday reflections freely with everyone.
Thank you for being part of this growing community.

P.S. Next Sunday, 29 November, I am beginning The Unexpected Christmas — 27 daily Advent reflections exploring the surprising people, overlooked details and extraordinary hope of the first Christmas. Together, we’ll look for God in the story we thought we knew.
I’d love you to join me.




Thank you for sharing your magical clerical collar trick. It is both hilariously funny and deeply disturbing to think how easily you can lose your humanity in people's views by so slight a change in dress. It's not so easy for a nun to change her habit, but something similar happened after Vatican II when Catholic female orders shifted from medieval costumes so they were less visibly "set apart." Once you announce an allegiance, you are stuck with whatever ignorant or insane ideas people attach to that entity. When I became sick and tired of the other-worldly assumptions my co-workers were making about my Christianity, I started smoking. (People smoked at work in their offices in those days, even in hospitals.) I shocked everyone. Cigarettes had the desired effect. But then I had a nasty little addiction to deal with after a while -- and I did not know then what everyone was about to learn about the dangers of nicotine. You have definitely opened the door to a deeper understanding of what at first seems like contradictory behaviour in Jesus. He was adapting His instructions to individuals and to specific circumstances. And, in regard to that other issue of His divine perfection, was learning how to adapt His approach along the way. I think Jesus was fully human and showed us what that means.